JAN 11 -12 COASTAL LOW LOOKING BIGGER… ITS COMING

Posted by wxrisk | GENERAL | Friday 7 January 2011 8:30 pm

1855  EST   7JAN

 
One of the things that I do differently and makes me  better  most other meteorologists on TV is that even when there  is no   a snowstorm coming I closely watched and follow weather models   beyond 48 hours.  Beyond three days…  Beyond six days   beyond 10 days.  All year  around.    But it is not just me– you will find this to be true with any energy or agricultural meteorologist because when you  are dealing with the timeframe is that we are dealing with you need every piece of inside information you can get.
 
There is a site on the Internet which you can access for free   run  by   NWS ‘s  department of environmental modeling center  ( EMC).  This department is responsible for developing maintaining and tracking all the various weather models that are used to see which weather model reforms the best and under what conditions. 
 
 It has long been known that the  18Z   GFS   run has been the most inaccurate and worst performer of the four   GFS Model   runs     ( 0z  6z  12z  and 18z).    Unfortunately  there are   TV meteorologists  out there… one of them  the Richmond…   that sees   the 18 Z   GFS  and has decided  for some incomprehensible reason …..that all the other data which came out today  that  showed significant snow coming for Central Virginia is now absolutely worthless.  This genius has decided to ditch all that the other   model data and use the 18Z  GFS   and thus   has lowered   his snow   numbers  to  wwell below   any other  Model Guidance  for  Tuesday Jan 11  event.
 
 It is clear that  he is unaware of how badly performing the 18z GFS  is.  That  much is   Obvious.  But there also seems to be a problem   with   the  reasoning.   Given that the event is still four days out why would any one throw out ALL the   other model data   today showing significant snowfall for Central Virginia and decide to go with one model which showed  much less snow?
 
The mind is simply boggles  by the  ahem reasoning.
 
We will start out by taking a look that the model data from early this morning.  Even though a lot of the model data on Thursday was pretty aggressive with the potential snow situation for Virginia and the Middle Atlantic states the European model was not.  The European model on    Tuesday  Wednesday and Thursday showed a flat wave of Low   with not a lot of development …moving off the Hatteras Coast with only a moderate amount of precipitation getting into Eastern Virginia.
 
And as I  have stated many times before…  The European model is the model choice for East coast winter storms   in the day  3  to day 8   range.
 
This image shows the shift in the European model which started this morning.  There are four maps the two top ones are the European  ensemble models .  It takes the Low pressure area of near the Savannah Coast moves up the Carolina Coast line then hooks  a right turn east of Norfolk.   The bottom 2  maps  are the 0z  JAN 7 GFS Ensemble  which show a similar pattern…  but here the   GFS is a little warmer over southeastern Virginia.   The 0z GFS   and  Canadian   had more  snow  and a Bigger Low further up the coast with up to an 10″ or  so of snow   over  DCA area.
  CLICK  ON ALL THE IMAGES   TO SEE  FULL SIZE  
 
 AT  12z  today the  GFS   however  backed off  that idea    as you can see  here.  The model shows a significant snow for west central and North Central North Carolina all of Virginia but especially central and eastern portions and the lower Maryland Eastern shore…  And like the European model insisted… hooks a  BIG right turn   out to sea.  This would mean that areas north end of DC into Boston would not see significant snowfall.
 
This image shows the precipitation forecast from the   12z GFS   Model.  As you can see the amounts are decent but not overwhelming…  And the dark blue band  gets into Richmond  and much of Eastern Virginia.
 
The reason why the  12 z GFS show this change  was  that  the Model  does NOT  have a   Upper Low  in the Jet stream forming  as the Low comes up the coast.
 
This image shows the overall jet stream pattern…  from the   12z GFS.  The blue circle shows the main piece of energy which is going to cause the low  pressure area to develop.  But as you can see it’s not closed off in the jet stream and   there fore  it is going to follow the blue arrow  and move off the Virginia Coast and take the low pressure area out to sea.
 
  IN    ORDER    TO     GET  A BIGGER  SNOWSTORM  FOR VA  MD   DCA  and into the Northeast   US…   we  HAVE     TO    GET  A    CLOSED     UPPER    LOW    IN THE    JET   TO FORM  AS THE    LOW COMES   UP THE    COAST.   
 
If that does not happen that what we are  looking at is a significant snowfall  But  not a major one. 
 
The   12z   Canadian model followed the same sort of development has the   GFS.  It no longer show to foot of snow over Washington DC Northern Virginia but instead had a band of moderate snow blowing across Kentucky West Virginia Virginia and Maryland… and the Low  taking a   right turn  out to sea  with with heavy snow being restricted to Southern New Jersey Eastern Long Island and Cape Cod  and Moderate snow  over   Northern NJ NYC  and  CT.
 However  the  12z  GFS   ensemble  mean   is of more aggressive in showing a bigger system for the Middle Atlantic coastal areas.  I did not accept this model is being valid.   However this was followed by the midday British model which did close off a Upper low  over  KY   and   WVA.  This causes the model to grab the surface low and pulling back towards the coast  the slows it down and deeps  it so you get a much more significant storm and heavy snow into the big cities of the I 95 corridor.
BRITISH MODEL    followed the  GFS  ensemble eman   with a    somewhat stronger   Low .
  And finally the afternoon European ensemble came out and it is even more bullish and aggressive with this whole system by developing an explosively along the North Carolina Virginia Coast and then tracking  it fairly close to the coast.  If the European ensemble mean is correct  this would provide significant if not heavy snow from northeastern Virginia up thru DCA  and  PHL  then  into  NJ  NYC  CT  Long Island    and  se  Mass. 
 
The fact that the  GFS  ensemble    the   British model and now the European   ensemble all show a stronger system …  That is closer to the coast    leaves the open to the possibility that the precipitation amounts may be increasing on some of the model runs as we go into the weekend ., Monday morning we could be looking at a much wetter system  then what it appears  to be today.

—————————————————-

1830    EST  JAN 5  

There is a free the newsletter which you can get from  me…   To see a sample   of the  newsletter     CLICK    HERE.   The newsletter covers the next two weeks in Virginia and the neighboring regions and is issued twice a week…  Usually the Sunday afternoon or evenings and again on Thursday morning.  After the winter season of course the  VIRGINA   2 WEEK  FORECAST  Newsletter  continues so you complain your warm weather activity 2 and 3  weeks ahead.  If you wanna get on the mailing list…  Just drop me a line
 at     [email protected]   and   say     ”HEY   DT   put me on the mailing list.” 

I am running way behind schedule to date because of  2 hour orthodontist  appointment for my son.  Normallly  this  UPDATE  would be online by 430   OR  5:00 PM 

Later on this evening I will be issuing some snow maps for the arctic Low which is going to develop off the New England Coast  JAN 7-8.  The model data is pretty clear that there is going to be a  NORULND  trough which is a special  and somewhat rare weather feature.   The  Norlund trough  will   extend over Eastern NY  State  into  western  CT  and portions of Long Island  into the Low itself.   This   1st GUESS  snow map it is going to be a high risk forecast since getting these sorts of features    right  can be very difficult.  I would not at all be surprised if over the high terrain of southeastern New York Hudson Valley into southwest Connecticut  12″   or more of snow  fell… yet  50 miles  away   Nothing  falls.   

OK and lets move on to the bigger event for January 11.  I have been talking about this event since December 28 – 29 and yesterday when all the model data was showing the inland track of the Low…  and possibly going up the spine of the Appalachians  with a late  redevelopment   of the Low to the coast…   I tried to argue that the solution was not viable given the overall pattern.   Instead I took a lot of nasty comments  from the ignorant weenies  in  the gallery. 

Today I looked a helluva lot smarter to them that I did yesterday.    This really is NOT  rocket science but if you are so desperate and hung up about getting a snow storm in your backyard that you simply ignore the actual weather pattern and latch onto what ever model is giving you a big snow…  then you always going to be wrong and always going to be behind the eight ball. 

It’s meteorology  NOT Modelology…  And  yesterday far too many    people  who knew  better were practicing that. 

Remember   weather  patterns of drive weather features and the weather models  tried to simulate  actual weather patterns.   Sometimes   weather models…  either one or all of them ….can miss features which cause  Models  to   behave erratically   and we  see model flip flops and reversals. 

That being said the important lesson that we have learned from the DEC   26th big East coast storm  is that when ALL of the weather models at the same time / Model  cycle  change  course    and they ALL show the   same  thing…  it usually means something significant.   If you recall    on DEC 24  the weather models which had showed the big East coast storm for several days due the reversal and showed no storm at all.  However on Friday afternoon the weather models southerly change course and showed a significant snow up and down the East coast with a very strong area of Low pressure . 

No one was sure what to make of this dramatic turn of events   but when ALL  of the 18z  DEC  24   Models  and ALL   of the  0z DEC 25   weather Model came out and showed the trend continuing…  That dramatic shift should have been interpreted as a major change.  Instead what we saw was incremental changes on most of the TV stations and NWS  forecast  over  eastern  VA and the Lower  MD  eastern  shore. 

SUMMARY…. The   **threat**    for seeing significant snowfall –over 6″+– has increased over much of central and eastern NC and eastern half of VA.    There is also the increase in the risk of seeing significant snow into the big cities of I 95.    But there is still equally High risk that the Low will slide off the coast before the heavy snow reaches those big cities in the Northeast.    Once again far western NC   western  VA and western MD   could miss out on the significant snow.
 
  
  
WE start out by    reminding    folks  that the  Tuesday 12z  GFS  and Canadian  weather models showed  the inland track.   I argued vociferously against this solution because of the overall pattern.  Sure enough  the   early morning   (0z)  GFS and Canadian models shifted the Low’s track  to the south  by  300-400 Miles!  
This first image will help explain the overall situation and what has to happen for VA  NC  MD  and DE to see a major snowstorm on January 11. 
As you can see the there are two important features or pieces of energy in the jet stream which in the weather business we call SHORT WAVES.   One is located over Western Texas the other one over the Pacific Northwest.  Many of the weather models had been taking this system as it comes out of TX and squashing it  as it moves  towards  Georgia.   Last night the Canadian model was suggesting that this feature over Western TX is going to hold together as it comes into GA which will allow the second piece of energy to merge or Phase  into one big system.  This in turn would produce a significant coastal storm. 
 
 Got it?  

We can see how the Canadian model does this over these next two images.  At 120 and 132 hours  the Model  shows feature #1 holding together quite nicely and allowing the phasing to take place. 

       

At the surface this is what the early WED morning Canadian model looked like.  As you can see   the Model   has a major Low over the Gulf coast states which moves into the Carolinas and Virginia and  brings a  glancing blow to central and Eastern MD VA and Southern NJ. 

 

The 0z European model whch we can see here at  96  and  120 hrs  also has a very strong feature over Texas. ( LEFT  side  maps Jet stream  RIGHT  side  maps  surface) .       But at 120 HRS     feature   #1 is getting washed out or crushed as it moves into AL and GA.  Because the European model  is killing the first feature ….when the second piece of energy catches up to it   it becomes much harder  to develop a significant coastal storm.  

 

See?       The 0z  WED   GFS had a very suppressed system as it almost always does when you dealing with very cold arctic air over the eastern Conus so my opinion it’s not even worth talking about. 

The  6z   WED GFS was a little better and had the system stronger that was   closer to the coast and at significant snow over much of NC and   MD. 

 The WED 12z GFS was pretty close to the same as the  6Z GFS  with moderate snow over portions of NC into  central and Eastern VA   but very little  snow  North of Fredericksburg and Charlottesville. 

The important run was the Canadian model from this afternoon because there was widespread belief that is as impressive as the Canadian model was early Wednesday morning… the 12z  Canadian model would probably not show that sort of impressive set up.  However the Canadian model DID hold the stormy snowy pattern  and if anything increased it .    

 Here is the jet stream map from the  12z  WED   Canadian valid for Monday night January 9.    Then  model has   feature  #1  looking   very strong …quite vigorous over  ARK northern MS  and Western TN and because the model has    this  feature   so strong the second feature coming out of the central Rockies   can merge or PHASE.      This results in the  12z  wed afternoon Canadian model showing a major winter storm with a large area of heavy snow covering all VA   MD   into  WVA nd  eastern  KY    and  by   day 7… JAN 12 then heavy snow spreads into  NJ  PHL  NYC  Long Island and  CT. 

            

As promising as all this may be the we still have to be concerned that two things could go wrong with this major winter storm threat. 

 FIRST   the lead  Piece  of  energy   (short wave)   coming at a Texas has got to survive.  If it does not survue and it gets  SQUASHED     there will be no big snow  for   anyone! 

Second one has to be concerned that the system does not slide out to the south and east.  We can get a very nice Low but its not at all certain that   the Low  is  going  to make it   as far N as the Canadian model is  now showing.  

And we also have to be concerned that the   12z  European model continues to show system  #1 — the  lead piece of energy over  TX– getting squashed as it comes east into  GA. 

 

However if you look closely you will see that with each model cycle  of  the European model..  system #1  is still  be squashed .  BUT…. the model  is doing  this  later and later.  

The delay in crushing the the first system means  that    there is More energy   so that a Phase  CAN  take place.      Over the last few runs the European model has developed heavy widespread rains across all of the gulf coast states and significant snow in portions of Northern Arkansas Tennessee Northern Mississippi Northern Alabama and Georgia.  

We can see this slow a subtle shift in the European by taking a look at this image.  The top maps deferred to the early morning Wednesday European model run…  And the bottom maps   are the  Wednesday  afternoon European model run.     These map s may look the same but there are subtle differences and the precipitation shield is much stronger on the bottom maps….  the  12z  WED      European Model. 

     

EURO  ENSEMBLE   0Z   vs   12z 

 

 The 0z  European  model run had No snow over Raliegh or Richmond and only a little snow over  Norfolk.   But the   12z  Wed European…   has  a LOT more precip  over  central and  eastern  NC   and   eastern  half of  VA.   (about  3″  at  Richmond   and 6″  at   Raliegh into  Noroflk) .  While this is NOT  as much as  the Canadian it is a increase from the  0z   European Model run. 

9 Comments »

  1. Comment by Brian — January 6, 2011 @ 1:27 am

    Very interesting about the Canadian model. Can’t say I’m not pulling for it. I noticed the European today did have the storm a little more “together,” just pulling off the coast in time to give a glancing blow to southern MD. The trending is looking decent for snow as of tonight.

    What are your predictions for the Central MD area? We’ve been in a donut hole all winter and it seems like if this thing retrogrades back a little like the last one the same thing could happen, although I see it going out to see as a much more likely option.

    Also, I was wondering where I can access a Canadian model, a UK model, or a Euro model that takes me this far out. The site I use only allows me to go out about 84 hours with the Canadian and the Uk, which seem to be the next most popular picks with the weather folk.

    Hope to hear back.

  2. Comment by Cathy G — January 6, 2011 @ 1:29 am

    Thanks for the update, we look for them daily! Since we are still 6-7 days out from The Next Big Event in Richmond, we’ll be following this storm closely. Thanks again!

  3. Comment by Patrick Casey — January 6, 2011 @ 1:49 am

    Thats pretty inteesting – never knew what it took to make a snowstorm. Thanks

  4. Comment by johnnierat — January 6, 2011 @ 2:01 am

    Excellent analysis of the potential event early next week. Here on the outskirts of Washington, DC, it appears the we are right on the cusp of a major snowstorm next week, if the Canadian model output should materialize. It would be a shame to waste all of the cold air that has enveloped the mid-Atlantic region. Cold and dry is boring, and makes for a lot of static shock. Give me at least one major snow event before the cold air retreats back north of the Canadian border. Bring it on!
    Keep up the excellent work. I will be following your blog very closely. Thank you.

  5. Comment by GA Knight — January 6, 2011 @ 12:08 pm

    Being in a business which mandates I be IN the weather even if it immobilizes a city/county/neighborhood, I am one who truly appreciates an accurate, and frank discussion of the weather. As I see it, you call them as you see them, not as others would wish it to be.
    Thanks.

  6. Comment by addison Livey — January 6, 2011 @ 1:49 pm

    So, basically you are saying what…right now there is a 30% chance of things lining up for a storm? 50%? 100% chance of the storm forming and hitting us? There were a lot of “ifs”. What does that mean? What are the odds?

  7. Comment by Nathan — January 6, 2011 @ 8:47 pm

    I love this website, I look forward to snow in the Richmond area. Keep up the good work. You do a great job of how the storms track and why we should or should not get what we do.

  8. Comment by Peggy B — January 7, 2011 @ 1:06 am

    Thanks DT – hoping for no snow but REALLY appreciate your explaining why, when and the possibilities – much appreciated!

  9. Comment by Steve — January 8, 2011 @ 1:00 pm

    Great in depth analysis. However,I would suggest proofreading for spelling and grammar before posting. Also, why is it necessary to attack your competitors? Let the superiority of your forecasts prove how good you are. Demeaning others only makes you look smaller and mean spirited, and is not a good way to build business.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment