|
ARCHIVE of 2005 SEASON FORECASTS / DISCUSSIONS:
click Here HURRICANE FORECASTS & DISCUSSION
2004 click
HERE
REVIEW OF ALL OF WXRISK
ISABEL FORECASTS HERE
ANALYSIS:
FORECAST DISCUSSIONS issued
830 AM EDT... AND 730PM (ONCE
a TC crosses 60 W Longitude... there is a Midday update)
6PM TUESDAY AUG 29
for some reason
the hurricane Center appears to be surprised that during the day Ernesto did
not undergo any sort of significant intensification... but as I said here
yesterday this lack on intensification really should not be a surprise. In
order for tropical system to undergo the sort of ordinary development one
might expect with the system moving through the very warm waters of the
Florida Straits you have to have some sore low-level organized circulation
center and the fact is that the guts of this system got ripped up with its
prolonged track over southeastern Cuba. So instead of intensifying Ernesto
is just trying to rebuild its core as it tracks over the Florida Straits...
with the result it will only be a ordinary insignificant tropical storm when
it makes land fall in southeastern Florida tomorrow.
I have no changes for the track into North Carolina and eastern Virginia...
the large high over southeastern Canada will provide a significant pressure
gradient for Northeast and allow a system to have a fairly strong Wind field
along northern Atlantic and southeast New England coastal areas. However
this is really not going to be a significant tropical East Coast event for
anybody. Despite the media hype and hysteria a weak category one hurricane
over southeastern North Carolina is simply not a big deal. It is good
however for TV ratings.
7AM TUESDAY AUG 29
Ernesto finally cleared the north coast south eastern Cuba this morning
around 3- 4 am EDT... and I have to tell you that this system looks like
crap. I am not even sure it still is a tropical organized system at this
point. There has been a general increase in overall connection so I supposed
one could still make the case that there is a close to system now entering
the Florida Straits but it the idea that Ernesto might rebuild to hurricane
status even a week to category one at this point time looks to be BOGUS.
As for the rest of the forecasts are really do not had any changes. It seems
to me that Ernesto has a good chance of reaching a minimal category one
hurricane before making land fall near Wilmington North Carolina in two
days. Don't be surprised if by the time Ernesto is off the southeast North
Carolina coast the system looks the best that it has since it was born!
5PM MONDAY AUG 28
well everything that I talked about in my earlier discussions has pretty
much occurred during the daytime hours. Ernesto is essentially none
significant system with the entire low-level structure now exposed and
devoid of any sort of convection with the LLC over southeastern Cuba . Even
worse the center is drifting and has ended its steady Northwest movement...
if anything the LLC -- low level center-- is drifting WNW. Not surprisingly
some of the hurricane models which earlier were forecasting significant
intensification when Ernesto cost over into the Florida Straits now backed
WAY off that idea. I do not have a problem issuing the hurricane watch for
southern Florida but the issuance of the hurricane warnings in my opinion is
not needed...
I'm glad to see that the hurricane Center is finally backed off the talk of
Ernesto possibly reaching category 2/3 status before making land fall again
in southeastern Florida. That is simply not going to happen and anybody who
asserts it is really should shut up and stop talking about weather.
The next question has to do with what happens with Ernesto when he leaves
the southeast Florida and moves out into the coastal waters off of Northern
Florida Georgia and South Carolina. This will be the best chance for the
system to reached hurricane status again and it also follows the seasonal
trends all of the 2006 hurricane season... which so far has been highly
centered on the idea that systems within the topics have trouble developing
by systems which moved north of 20-25N latitude... develop fairly quickly.
This looks to me to be a classic East Coast borderline hurricane tropical
storm situation with a second land fall probably close to Wilmington North
Carolina and thru either central / or eastern Virginia.
Down the road the readl issue is going to be what Ernesto does inland over
eastern NC/ sotueast VA... does he turn northwest into western Pennsylvania
or turn Northeast and parallel the northeast Coast. ? There is a third
solution of course which is being somewhat overlooked... the system
fragments .... with part of it gettiong absorbed by the next eastern US
trough ... while the convection and heavy rain stays on the Coast.
6AM
EDT MONDAY AUG 28
Well I have to tell you I was not really happy with the TPC discussion from
the hurricane Center this morning regarding the possible developments and
tracks of Ernesto. First the system is clearly a tropical storm but it is
also a damaged one and the low-level center not looking very healthy. The
convective bursts seem to be all on one side of the system. Second while
there is considerably more hurricane model agreement with the track Ernesto
Paul southeastern Cuba for the Florida Straits and into southeastern Florida
the overall hurricane intensity forecast seemed to be to be way overdone.
The official forecast does not call for any intensification above a category
1 hurricane when he crosses over into the Florida Straits but I find this to
be a dubious proposition as well. Most of the hurricane models are
forecasting a much stronger system with Ernesto possibly reaching borderline
category 2/3 status as the nearest southeastern Florida. So what has
happened is the hurricane Center has taken a compromise between the very
weak and ragged system we currently have and the very strong hurricane model
intensification that is being forecasted they come up with a category one
hurricane. On top that we still do not yet know how long Ernesto is going to
be over Cuba and what sort of shape he will be when he comes off.
Thus we are faced with two very risky / uncertain propositions which 1) a
fairly short interval over southeastern Cuba and 2) Ernesto will still be a
well organized system that moves into the Florida Straits... allowing for at
least SOME intensification before making land fall in southeast Florida.
8PM SUNDAY AUG 27
During
the daytime hours are nest oh which was a minimal hurricane turned to the
Northwest a little that and as a result its close proximity to the southwest
peninsula of Haiti during the afternoon and the MSLP rose to 1004 MB. By any
scale that you wish to use Ernesto is a significantly weaker system that is
in deep trouble and rapidly falling apart. The 5 pm. Advisory from TPC
asserts that there is a window of opportunity where are Ernesto might reach
strengthen again before making land fall over southeastern Cuba but I do not
see that as a significant threat or probability or even a reasonable chance
at this point. The best that the system can reasonably expect is to hold its
current strength without weakening any further.
The track towards the Northwest and then turn north continues and all of
this stems from the fact that the low-level center of the system shifted
dramatically to the north overnight and the system reached hurricane
strength this morning. It is pretty clear now that Ernesto is going to pass
north and east of the north side of Jamaica. The real question is what sort
trajectory will this system develop as it crosses southeastern Cuba.
The odds are very strong that this is not going to be a significant system
for any portion of Florida despite the media hysteria which is sweeping the
country and many of the meteorological weather which are filled with all
sorts of mass hysteria and pathetic weenie-ism.
If Ernesto continues on a WNW / NW track he would likely spend a
considerable amount of time over southeastern Cuba and as result fall apart
even further. While this does place is system closer to southern Florida...
the prolonged interval over southeastern Cuba ensures that the system will
only have a short interval of time over the Florida Straits before it makes
land fall in the southern tip of Florida... and therefore a short window all
opportunity to strengthen. In this particular scenario Ernesto would
probably only build back to a strong TS stsus and NOT make Hurricane status.
On the other hand Ernesto continues to make a sharp Northwest track and then
turn more to the North... this would allow for much shorter interval over
eastern Cuba and the system would reach the very warm waters off the
southwest Bahamas much sooner. Ergo we would have a more organized system
that could intensify much faster... however in this scenario the system is
likely to pass well EAST of southern Florida and in fact would probably miss
the East Coast entirely because Ernesto will have already turned early to
the north... which dramatically increases the probability of a sharp recurve.
8AM SUNDAY
AUG 27
There Is
not a lot to change here in my Sunday morning update from the thinking I
posted on Saturday evening. Ernesto now a minimal hurricane is clearly in
much better shape than it was just 12 and 24 hours ago as the large upper
level Low which was over Jamaica and central Cuba is now moving towards the
Central America Coast.
The issue still remains where are Ernesto was going to pass with regard to
Jamaica. Most of the hurricane models here at 6Z and 12Z show a track across
the south side of Cuba for considerable period of time and then into the
eastern Gulf of Mexico with a turn towards the big bend of Florida or the
Florida Panhandle.
In a general sense I do not have particular problem with this idea/ track
but I am not yet convinced that it's going to pass north of Jamaica. Let us
see what the TPC says on their 11 AM advisory as to what the current heading
is . Not am I at all convinced that it's going to pass along a significant
portion of Cuba although Ernesto will be affected by the close proximity.
Still I think much of the core of Ernesto could pass between Jamaica and
Cuba and this would mean only a very brief passage across the Western tip of
Cuba.
I continue to be amazed at how the first tropical cyclone rule is once again
asserting itself. Go back and take a look at the first system of the season
Alberto and you'll see a track amazingly similar to lower saying with
Ernesto and the close to itself the tropical cyclone named Beryl -- well it
is just a thing of beauty to see. Of course I have to emphasize again that
this first tropical cyclone of the season RULE does not always work in every
single hurricane season. But clearly is working this hurricane season.
8PM
SATURDAY
The reformation of the low-level
center (LLC) of Ernesto this evening has thrown most of the hurricane model
guidance and forecasts into the crapper and this is also true with my
forecast. I made it clear that from the get go that IMO Ernesto was going to
be a Hurricane passing through the Yucatán Channel and make Landfall
somewhere in the Upper Texas coast or perhaps into Southwest Louisiana. That
idea/ forecast was based upon the idea that Ernesto was going to pass close
to or just south of Jamaica and therefore make a W-I-D-E-R or slower turn as
the shortwave comes through the Lower Plains and Mississippi Valley and
erodes the western side of the High-pressure Ridge over the southeastern US.
Clearly however with the center reforming this evening and apparently to the
north or northeast of where the LLC had been... ALL of Model tracks and
forecasts are shifted correspondingly to the north and this increases the
probability that Ernesto is going to pass north of Jamaica.
Therefore the first critical benchmark in this storm is going to be Jamaica
and whether or not Ernesto -- likely to be a hurricane by Sunday morning--
passes north or south love that island.
I suspect that come 11 p.m. this evening the hurricane Center is going to
show he even further north track with Ernesto taking him over a significant
portion of at least western Cuba and then a much sharper turn over Eastern
Gulf of Mexico. This of course would spare Texas coast as well as most of
Louisiana and the heart of the natural gas platforms in the north central
and Northwestern Gulf... and will increase the concern and media coverage
for the western side of Florida including Florida Panhandle.
Sometimes focusing on the latest run of the hurricane models as a group or a
individual run of the GFDL or Euro is useful. In ERNESTO's case it is
NOT.... it is a complete waste of time... because the center has been
reforming and jumping to the NE. Moore over many of the hurricane models are
run off the operational GFS and as of this writing Saturday evening the last
14 lines of the GFS has shown no significant system beyond 36 hours. Every
single run of the last 14 GFS models as a shown Ernesto either dissipating
or becoming an open wave and yet here we are with Ernesto strengthening in
what has been a fairly hostile environment ...which is now only beginning to
improve slowly. And still the operational GFS has no clue that Ernesto is
going to survive past the next 36 hours.
the 18z Sat & 0z Sunday Hurricane models model DO shift the tracks all
North-- which of course means that Ernesto would cut across More of Cuba and
sharper turn to the N then NE... over the eastern Gulf. But again as I
stated above this is all based upon the idea that Ernesto is going to take a
more Northwest were track because the center has reformed to the north and
east. My point is that we dont know that.... it is entirely possible that he
will resume his 285-290 heading overnight and Sunday.
Thus with the models being so whacky one way of getting around this is to
use the DT amazing BENCH MARK system... SYNOPTICALLY we know what IS going
to happen in a GENERAL sense...
Tthe western side of the large ridge over the SE states will weaken... and
this will allow for Ernesto to turn to the NW then N sooner ... and thus
Ernesto will track into and through the eastern Gulf of Mexico.
USING the BENCHMARK system we can develop a couple of different scenarios
which will tell us How fast and when this turn is going to occur.... the 1ST
BENCHMARK will be the island of JAMAICA ...
CONCEPTUALLY...keeping the overall synoptic pattern in your mind.... you can
see how this works... IF Ernesto passes over or south of that Island then we
are looking at a wider turn.... with Ernesto much more likely to pass thru
the Yucatan channel and making a WIDER more gradual turn into the western /
central Gulf... ergo bad news for New Orleans and NAT Gas.
IF Ernesto passes NORTH of that Island then we are looking at a SHARPER
turn.... with Ernesto passing thru the WESTERN Cuba .... which of course
means a weaker system and it means the western side of the High is weaker so
a turn to the N then NE over the eastern Gulf would seems to be a better bet
1PM SATURDAY AUG
26
The Midday
SAT run of the operational GFS ( hereafter called
op- GFS) shows something that is not
only whacky but very unlikely.
It loses the TC of course
after 48 hours but the GFS has been doing that
over the past 3 days with every
single run anyway. This time
the Model for some reason LOSES the Big Ridge over the
SE states in less than 48 hours and
shifts it across eastern Cuba by 60 hours!!!!
from there the model takes a weaken system into the south
or sw side of Florida.
Let me be clear
-- that solution is 1000% CRAP and the the 12z
GFS is flat out wrong and is NOT repeat NOT worthy of any consideration.
The idea of ERNESTO is going to cross Cuba
in 60 hours then into south FL is based on 2 critical issues..
First the 12z GFS has NO ridge over the SE states ... why the run of
the model which has showed this ridge
before.... now has such a violent change on this run I dont know but
its wrong... and this idea has no other
support for any of the other models. Second b/c there is
No Ridge the 12z Saturday op-model has Ernesto over the north
side of eastern Cuba in 60 hrs...
If
YOU think Ernesto ... which is still slowing down.. is going to be
North of eastern Cuba in 60 hrs you need to find to seek a betetr
understanding of how weather works.
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/nwprod/analysis/namer/gfs/12/images/gfs_85v_060m.gif[
Moreover over the last 14 runs of the
op-GFS have ONLY showed dissipation of the
TC.... thus when a Model that has been nothing BUT wrong
with regard to Ernesto ... is now showing a meteorological
impossibility I dont need to wait for a few more runs to decide this
idea is crap
3AM SATURDAY
AUG 26
Major
changes in the MR weather models
show ERNESTO possible impact in North central
and / or NE GULF late next week
FOLKS
I am taking a BIG step backwards from my idea of a TX hit ... but not
giving up on the idea completely --and shifting
the possible window of landfall as
it were.... to the north central Gulf coast as ell as the
NE Gulf coast ...... ( Fl Panhandle).
However I still do NOT Ernesto making any landfall on the
West side of the Florida Peninsula.
Consider the 1st TC of the season 'RULE' ... read
about it
HERE. This Year the " A" storm (ALBERTO) which
developed in the SE Gulf... crossed N FL then scooted off the se US
coast.... the B storm ( BERYL) did SORT of the same thing as it formed
off the SE coast and paralleled that
coast until it turned out to sea.....
http://weather.unisys.com/hurricane/atlantic/2006/ALBERTO/track.gif
http://weather.unisys.com/hurricane/atlantic/2006/BERYL/track.gif
Now we MIGHT Have the same thing setting up for ERNESTO...
if we assume on 72 hrs Ernesto is somewhere in the NW Caribbean he
will be undergoing rapid intensification with that huge RIDGE in the
Jet stream over Gulf .... a classic case of DIVERGENCE ALOFT -a.k.a.
"ventilation"...
This map depicts the operational GFS at
Middle layers of the atmosphere with ERNESTO
clearly seen nearing the Yucatan Channel
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/nwprod/analysis/namer/gfs/00/images/gfs_85v_096s.gif
500 MB at 84 hrs
Note as the HUGE ridge builds in s central Canada and brings on several
days of temps in M 90s which is near record that for late august in that
part of the world a strong short
wave (s/w ) is located over the central Plains.
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/nwprod/analysis/namer/gfs/00/images/gfs_500_084s.gif
By 108
the 0z GFS closes this
feature off into a ULL-- Upper Level low -- over the Midwest
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/nwprod/analysis/namer/gfs/00/images/gfs_500_084s.gif
note the HIGH or Ridge is STILL over FL and SE
at 300 MB ... but the western flank of the Ridge is
being worn
away but the winds over the central GULF are all S to N....
http://www.nco.ncep.noaa.gov/pmb/nwprod/analysis/namer/gfs/00/images/gfs_300_084s.gif
CRITICAL POINT... if the Upper low closes off further to the south -- see
the 0z cmc and new 0z SAT euro ... the western side of the HIGH over the SE
states will get ripped away and ERNESTO will turn N and even NNE in the
central Gulf
If Ernesto slows even more the Upper Low over the Midwest could be too
fat away and he stays on a WNW or NW course into TX
Indeed the new 0z SAT Euro and CMC shows a large HIGH over
DAY 6-7 over se Canada and some sort of - GET THIS -- COLD AIR DAMNING set
up!!! with the remains of Ernesto getting
pulled Northeast into the SE states as the Upper Low moves
slowly east. With the BIG High over S Quebec
providing east or NE winds heavy rains develops from the SE states ---
GA SC NC VA into much of the Mid Atlantic
I have seen the euro thru Day 9... and it if is right what a crappy
long holiday weekend for the East coast to close out the summer....
11PM WEDNESDAY AUG 23
FOLKS
On the IPR radio show THIS WEEK IN THE TROPICS
-- I talked about this lead wave on the ITCZ which has undergone
significant development Monday and it could develop
Tuesday... and . becoming a threat and a more serious one than
DEBBY...
The cite from CIRA that uses several parameters to forecast TC development
on Monday was at 8% above climno in that part of the s central Atlantic
http://rammb.cira.colostate.edu/projects/gparm/genesis.asp
IF I had to guess RIGHT NOW... ASSUMING 97L develops which seems to
be a good bet.... the system will track WNW and develop once it cross
65 west LONG and clears the north coast of S America.....
next if we assume ULL -- Upper Level Low -- over
the southeast Bahamas and far eastern
Cuba slides southwest as forecast towards central
America coast-- the stage could be set for
Major Hurricane in the Gulf of Mexico Next week...
They key will be the development by AL of
the global MR models on Day 6 and 7 that shows
a HUGE 500 mb ridge will be centered over the SE states...
This is a dangerous development..... the position of that HIGH... due N of
the the expected track of 97L into the northwest Caribbean would provide an
ideal environment ( divergence aloft which is
commonly referred to as VENTILATION) .... never mind
that the western Caribbean region is an ideal climo area as it
is. .
Speculating even longer term it would SEEM that the central and
western Gulf be more at risk ..... given the 500 MB maps at day 7 8 9 on the
12z Euro.... which shows the ridge over or just off the GA coast thus
protecting the eastern gulf to some degree... of course we are not that sure
of our facts and there are still many variables to consider...
for example IF the BIG Ridge over the SE
states were to slide East then the
system COULD turn NW and N
into the central Gulf coast areas.. |